The Jackal: Hekia Parata

Showing posts with label Hekia Parata. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hekia Parata. Show all posts

4 Sept 2014

Back to school for Hekia Parata

It's a pity that National party MPs often spend more time trying to make the numbers fit their flawed ideology so it appears their policies are working than actually doing their jobs properly.

In terms of the numbers concerning crime, unemployment, housing, debt and education, it seems the National party cannot even use a calculator properly. That's the distinct impression one gets after reading this article published by Stuff today:

Parata's higher teacher figures don't add up

Education Minister Hekia Parata has been forced to abandon a claim that National has presided over a 15 per cent increase in teachers - after revelations that Novopay clouded the numbers.

Parata has been quoted for several months saying that, under the present Government, "teacher numbers have gone up by 15 per cent".

But inquiries by The Dominion Post have shown most of the increase stems from a payroll error.

Teacher numbers are recorded in two ways by the ministry - by a head count, and by fulltime teacher equivalents (FTTE).

The head count, which includes fulltime and part-time or relief teachers, increased by 5882 between 2012 and 2013.

The ministry has now revealed this is due to relief teachers not being recorded in a consistent way before the switch to Novopay.

The revised head count shows a 6.5 per cent increase in teachers, from 55,124 in 2008 to 58,707 this year.

The number of FTTEs has risen by 4 per cent over that period - but further inquiries show almost half of those have been funded by individual schools, not by the ministry.

The Education Minister was not only wrong about the numbers, she was trying to take credit for an increase that wasn't being funded by the government. But if that wasn't bad enough,  Hekia Parata failed to come clean about the botched numbers she had been using.

Parata was told by the ministry on Monday morning that her earlier claim did not stack up, and in a radio interview shortly afterwards she made no mention of the 15 per cent increase.

This is standard procedure for National MPs. They make a bunch of incorrect statements, people find out the truth, then they simply go quiet. Unfortunately many of the people who initially heard the incorrect information are left believing what's in effect a bunch of baloney!

Clearly such disinformation ensures that a large amount of Kiwis are making decisions based on incorrect information. In my opinion, that's not a good situation for New Zealand to be in.

National party MPs certainly don't usually make a correcting statement to anywhere near the degree of their initial lies. In fact they hardly ever acknowledge that they were wrong at all. In my opinion such dishonest people shouldn't be in power.

17 Jun 2013

Where the buck should stop

Today, the NZ Herald reported:

...It is now common practice, when things go wrong, for ministers - not to defend their officials, but to blame them - as a means of avoiding any responsibility themselves.

The most recent and egregious example is the outfall from the Novopay debacle. A process that has created huge damage to an important public sector undertaking - our schools - was monitored and eventually signed off by three ministers; when they put their signatures to the sign-off, they in effect accepted responsibility for what they had decided.

We are now told that they did not know what they were signing because they had been provided with inaccurate information by their officials. The consequence is that the senior officials involved have been hung out to dry; two have departed (the second under threat of an investigation) and the pressure is mounting against the third.

The ministers sail on unchallenged and unaffected. It was not, it seems, anything to do with them. In this, they are following an unfortunate precedent set - among others - by Murray McCully.

Considering there's a complete lack of any ministerial accountability, one has to ask the question; do we really need a government at all? If all a Minister of the Crown needs to do is pass the buck down the chain of command in order to save their own hides, then what use are they?

I ask because with big business effectively owning the government, more and more decisions are being made that only benefit the 2 per cent, while the vast majority of people are paying a very high price indeed for a failing system. Clearly the current situation is detrimental to democracy, and verily to society in general as well.

There simply isn’t any progress when Ministers continually make the wrong decisions because it suits their business interests or defunct ideology, and without any consequences for those wrong decisions, how can we hope the current lot of errant Ministers will start making the right decisions instead?

12 Jun 2013

Make way for Noddy

16 Mar 2013

Quick! Blame the teachers

Today, the NZ Herald reported:

Up to half New Zealand's primary teachers may not have enough maths knowledge to teach children properly under new methods, says the education expert who introduced the changes.

We're not talking about rocket science here... With most if not all teachers having the skills to teach the curriculum required.

Professor Wright told the Weekend Herald the new methods were phenomenally successful when used in schools with strong leadership, a stable workforce and a culture of improvement and well-monitored student achievement.

But reformers might have overestimated the knowledge and confidence of many non-specialist primary teachers whose academic strengths were not in maths.

So now you have to be a specialist to teach times tables?

"Maybe we have to admit that we needed to provide more structured support for teachers than we did.

"In the ideal world, everyone would be able to run with this. Maybe they can't.

"I thought 50 per cent of the teachers were doing a fantastic job ... We just needed to have the other back-up plan, maybe, something more structured for those that it didn't work so well for."

Actually, the failure of the new system isn't because of teachers, its because the system they must use assumes that children already have basic maths skills when in many cases they don't.

Education Minister Hekia Parata described the results as "extremely concerning".

Somehow I doubt Parata will increase funding to ensure struggling students get the help they require. In fact having our schooling system underperforming will give the government the excuse they need to implement charter schools, which will in turn not improve educational outcomes at all.

Professor Wright co-ordinated the project from 2000 to 2010.

No wonder Wright is trying to blame the teachers then... He obviously cannot bring himself to admit that it's his system that's flawed.

Professor Wright said New Zealand had a longstanding difficulty finding teachers who were confident and knowledgeable teaching maths. Part of the problem was the low entry standard for teacher training and the limited time trainees had to study maths education, compounded by the shift from four to three-year teaching degrees.

If a low entry standard for teachers was the problem, then having no entry standard under a privatised schooling system National propose is obviously not the answer... Increasing class sizes and Novopay are also not the answer.

It should also be said that there hasn't been a reduction in the quality of teachers to cause such a reduction in outcomes. What has happened instead is an increase in poverty, with many more kids going to school hungry. Children simply cannot learn properly without sustenance.

But most of the struggling teachers were those already in the workforce, suggesting the real answer was better on-the-job training - like a maths version of Reading Recovery, which upskilled teachers as well as students.

So, Wrights' answer is to do the same thing again, which hasn't worked. The Numeracy Development Project that was designed to lift student performance by improving teachers' understanding has been a failure, which means Wrights advice shouldn't be listened to.

Instead, early childhood education, one on one teaching time and the welfare of our children all need to be increased so they're able to learn properly, and only the government can ensure that happens. Simply blaming teachers for the governments failure won't ensure kids can do the basics.

31 Jan 2013

Hekia Parata - Asshole of the Week

Today, the NZ Herald reported:

Education Minister Hekia Parata has been blasted for calling it "karma" that staff in her own ministry had not been paid, as she faced more controversy on her first day back.

Ms Parata, who survived a Cabinet reshuffle last week, was asked on her way into Parliament yesterday if she had been briefed on Education Ministry staff not being paid today,

"Yeah, karma eh," she replied.

This is no bloody joke! People are going without an income, which can have serious consequences especially for those on tight budgets. How exactly does Parata think teacher's are maintaining themselves, servicing bills and paying rent when there's no consistency with their incomes?

Novapay is an indictment on just how inept the National government under John Key's "leadership" has become. Not only did National Minister's ignore advise that Novopay wasn't up to scratch in the first place, they've been entirely remiss in fixing the problem, a problem they've known about for a very long time.

The Public Service Association national secretary, Brenda Pilott, slammed Ms Parata for her response, saying ministry staff had worked hard to try to solve Novopay issues.

"The minister should not be making such flippant remarks about ministry staff which, at the same time, seem to make light of the whole Novopay debacle," Ms Pilott said.


"The fact is there are many ministry staff who have been working very hard to try and pick up the pieces and help fix the Novopay problems.

"For their minister to then turn around and joke about the fact they themselves haven't been paid is pretty unacceptable.

"What would be real karma is for Hekia Parata not to be paid."

I bet Parata would jump into action if it was her considerable pay packet that was being messed with.

As Minister of Education, Parata is directly responsible for the continued incompetence in regard to the Novopay debacle. She should do the right thing and resign forthwith, because her flippancy and continued blundering clearly displays a lack of concern, a lack of concern because she obviously doesn't give a damn.

Despite the Novopay Governance Board member, Leanne Gibson, promising over a month ago that Novopay would be sorted in two weeks time, the extensive problems don't look likely to be fixed under the current administration anytime soon.

So for her continued mismanagement, incompetence and now obvious disregard, Hekia Parata wins this week's asshole award. 2014 is too long to wait for the opportunity to vote her out.


25 Jan 2013

Key should sack himself

Today, the NZ Herald reported:

Mr Key also defended his Education Minister, Hekia Parata, saying there had been calls to sack her.

"Over the last two months I've had plenty of people telling me I should sack Hekia Parata. I challenge you, name one person who cares more about Maori kids doing well in education in New Zealand that beats Hekia Parata. You won't name anyone, because she cares almost more than any of us that those young Maori kids succeed and she is succeeding."

That doesn't make sense... Parata cares almost more than any of us but nobody else cares more about Maori kids? Yet another logical fallacy by the so-called Prime Minister of New Zealand.

I think Key has entirely lost it... If Parata actually cared about the educational outcome of Maori children she would start showing that by doing her job properly. You simply don't get good outcomes by attacking teachers and their schools, it's as simple as that.

Not only has National done its best to undermine teachers by implementing a pay system that was never going to be up to scratch, they've threatened to close schools, reduce teacher numbers, increase their workloads, introduce unqualified teachers to undercut them and generally screw with what is a world class education system.

Then there is the fact that inequality and poverty are at unprecedented levels under a National government. Poverty impacts greatly on student's ability to learn or even attend school for that matter. Poverty leads to sickness and unwell children simply cannot attend school.

So that's the legacy Parata is leaving for our children. In my opinion Key should sack her forthwith... He should also sack himself while he's at it.

24 Dec 2012

Asshole of the Year - 2012

Welcome to The Jackal's prestigious Asshole of the Year Awards for 2012. The Jackal has been running a weekly asshole award with recipients automatically nominated for the coveted Asshole of the Year Award. It's what you've all been waiting for... Here are the nominees:


The previous National party lister, Greg White, won an Asshole Award for having the clear stench of corruption about him. Through his various conflicts of interest and underhanded dealings the asshole ensured a Taranaki iwi lost almost $20 million in dodgy investments Greg White had set up. The money has not been recovered and the conman has not been held to account.


The usually thoughtful Gareth Morgan won an Asshole Award for his ranting about "lefties, extremists, nutters," the "green extreme" and the "loony left" and saying that they are inhibiting their causes. Unfortunately the entrepreneur and philanthropist's inability to control himself has often undermined much of the good work he does concerning the environment, with many environmentalists now not giving him the time of day.


Mark Unsworth of government relations consultancy Saunders Unsworth, is perhaps the best example of a capitalist running dog that New Zealand has ever seen. His despicable attack on Massey University environmental scientist Dr Mike Joy for speaking out about environmental pollution was totally unacceptable! His attempt to use a position of power to try and close somebody down just because of what they're saying is why the prick won an Asshole Award... And rightly so.


Those who know Louis Crimp and what he believes in will fully understand why he's won an Asshole Award. The thoroughly racist Act party financial backer is as deluded as they come and typifies the old bigoted fool! People like Louis Crimp are why the Act party will not be around after the next election.


The ever repugnant Cameron Slater won an Asshole Award for yet another feckless rant about how terrible Winston Peters is and failing to check the facts. The deluded right wing propagandist was proven completely wrong about what Peter's said when the Teapot Tape transcript was leaked to the public.

Despite the transcript proving Slater to be full of shit with his accusations about the NZ First leader, he still continued to promote his poisonous brand of disinformation. Anybody who keeps track of Slater's blog knows that he's a consummate liar... Believing what he writes is akin to believing the holocaust never happened.


Judge Raoul Neave won an Asshole Award for giving Guy Hallwright a slap on the hand with a wet bus ticket after he was found guilty of causing grievous bodily harm with reckless disregard.

There were some real doozy judgements this year that were completely disproportionate to the crimes committed. Raoul Neave unequivocally displayed that there is one law for the rich and another for the rest of us. The problem of rich people being able to buy their way out of more serious sentences is something that's so entrenched within our judicial system as to be somewhat unfixable. The problem is now so large and systemic that it's ignored by judges and politicians alike.


Tim Groser won an Asshole Award for spending up large again while on an all expenses paid first class trip to Paris costing the taxpayer $33,494 in airfares. However he has undoubtedly exceeded himself with other acts of assholism concerning the Kyoto protocol, with Groser's lack of negotiation skills leaving the rest of the world thinking Kiwi's must be a bunch of inbred hicks to have voted such an idiot into power.

The Minister for Climate Change Issues is obviously a climate change denier, with his ability to come up with the worst possible excuses for not dong anything about climate change having no equal. Similarly Groser's excuses for implementing the TPPA with it's entirely detrimental investor-state dispute provisions were entirely feckless. Groser is more than just an asshole, he's also a traitor to New Zealand.


Bill English is the worst Minister of Finance New Zealand has ever had. Not only has he failed to meet every financial projection National has made, he's now going to go back on their promise and increase taxes to pay for Gerry Brownlee's roads of little significance. The Minister of Finance won't get us back in the black of course, because he couldn't organize a piss-up in a brewery. Through the disasterous neoliberal agenda Bill English has ensured that many generations of Kiwi's will be shackled through the governments unprecedented levels of debt that are now comparable to Greece's.

English won his Asshole Award for duping the public into believing asset sales would help reduce debt and also pay for new infrastructure spending, while actual figures from treasury show that the sales would come at a longterm financial loss. It's simply cheaper to pay the interest on the debt to service new capital expenditure than it is to lose the revenue streams from our SOE's.


The deluded fool John Roughan won an Asshole Award for arguing that the founding document of New Zealand, the Treaty of Waitangi, should simply be ignored, echoing the bad faith shown by National during asset sales negotiations. More recently Roughan tried to dismiss the massive privacy breach at ACC, arguing that the victims of sexual abuse and violent crimes weren't identified in the leaked information when they were. The old hack is clearly a lying fool! As long as people like Roughan get away with making up whatever bullshit they like to fit their own decrepit belief systems, we will continue to get manipulative articles in the NZ Herald that are written with all the skill of your average drunkard.


Other nominations for Asshole of the Year include:

Guy Hallwright
Jian Yang
Michael Christian & Mel Greig
Michael Laws
John Hansen
Paul Mackay
Phil Heatley
Kate Wilkinson
Bob Jones
John Tamihere
Ray Sharp
Tony Gibson
Richard Pearson
Vladimir Putin
Robert Bales
Mary Beth Sharp
Cathy Odgers

Runner-up:

Hekia Parata has been an unmitigated disaster as Minister of Education. From failing to read and understand Ministerial briefings to signing off on the Novopay disaster to flip flops that would make the best gymnast jealous, Parata has displayed an unprecedented level of incompetence and a gross lack of care in looking after our children's education.

After a lackluster propaganda campaign on increasing class sizes, only the most ideologically blinded Nact supporter believed that reducing the amount of teachers per student would equate to better learning outcomes. That's why Parata won an Asshole of the Week Award, for developing policy that was so clearly detrimental. Just like closing and merging schools in Christchurch, National's changes to teacher student ratios was a badly researched, poorly thought out and a terribly executed policy that threatened to kick our world class education system in the guts.

As the Minister of Education, the buck stops with Hekia Parata... She should be made to resign.

Second runner-up:

John Banks is a disingenuous bumbling right wing bigot that has no place within our halls of power. After intentionally trying to hide the $15,000 donation from SkyCity and the $50,000 donations from Kim Dotcom, Banks was unbelievably allowed to keep his position because of a Prime Minister who's equally if not more inept than the slimy Act party leader.

John Banks seems to have a knack at getting away with his dodgy dealings... In 2007 Banks along with former National Party leader Don Brash escaped prosecution for misleading investors in their Huljich Wealth Management fraud. That lack of accountability has clearly emboldened the conman to be even more dishonest.


Politicians need to be held to account when they're caught selling themselves to the highest bidder and the days of anonymous donations should be over. Businesses must not be allowed to purchase New Zealand's decision making process because of a few corrupt politicians... And clearly John Banks deserved his Asshole of the Week Award for displaying such a low standard of ethical behaviour.

Any Prime Minister with an ounce of credibility wouldn't have confidence in John Banks, and the fact that John Key allows such a moron to reside in his government speaks volumes.

Which brings us to the winner of this years Asshole Award, John Key.

The Prime Minister really did outdo himself this year, giving us lots and lots of reasons to think he's a complete asshole... From comments about David Beckham's intelligence, gay red shirts, eating maggots, the GCSB cover up, ignoring child poverty and failing to ensure Ministerial accountability, just to mention a few of his more overtly disgraceful acts. However the main reason Key has won is because he's entirely remorseless when caught out acting like the contemptible fool he is.


The smiling assassins juvenile attitude obviously makes him unsuitable to be the Prime Minister of New Zealand and his childish comments to provoke a spectacle on Waitangi day were in my opinion particularly despicable! Key's verbal diarrhea in the house of representatives and his ability to provide a veritable shit storm of disinformation knows no bounds. The antithesis of good leadership is clearly the frontrunner by a country mile and therefore John Key is Asshole of the Year for 2012. Hurrah!

13 Dec 2012

Everything Hekia Parata touches turns to shit

I watched some of the last sitting of the house of representatives yesterday, and was disappointing to see Hekia Parata dismissing concerns about her unlawful attempt to close an all girls' special needs school.

What really got my blood boiling though was that the Minister of Education didn't acknowledge any wrongdoing on her part whatsoever.

In fact Parata said the advice and reports that showed there would be an increased likelihood of sexual abuse of the 22 girls with special needs if she closed their school could simply be ignored because other advice said it wasn't an issue.

Where that ghost advice originated from or what exactly it was the Minister doesn't divulge, which makes me think that it doesn't exist other than as an excuse for Parata's incompetence.

That incompetence was grossly exhibited when she blatantly ignored clear advice that her decision would cause students harm, so it's no wonder Justice Robert Dobson has ruled against her moronic decision.

Yesterday, the NZ Herald reported:

In a reserved judgment in the High Court at Wellington, Justice Robert Dobson said Ms Parata's order to close Salisbury School, a residential establishment in Nelson, was unlawful because it relied on the possibility of sending some girls to live at Halswell School in Christchurch - a boys' special needs school.

Ms Parata had argued there was no evidence to suggest handicapped adolescent girls would be more vulnerable if moved together with boys. The plan was to have separate living quarters.

But Justice Dobson said that seeing the risks took "no great leap in logic".

The school had raised the issue during a meeting with Ms Parata, and a report about the vulnerability of girls at special needs schools had been earlier published for the Education Ministry and police.

"The minister's decision failed to have regard to available warning signals raised by and on behalf of the [school] trustees about greater levels of risk of abuse in a co-educational setting," Justice Dobson said.

Today, Tumeke reported:

Normally education policy is designed to have a positive effect on the lives of children. To specifically design a situation where special needs female students are sent to another special needs male school to face sexual and physical abuse 7 times greater in risk however seems to be more akin to building a children's playground out of depleted heavy uranium.

This is just the latest episode in a long series of Ministerial stuff-ups and only came to media attention when concerned citizens had to go to the high court in order to get another one of National's unbelievably stupid decisions overturned.

The cost to the tax-payer for yet another court case against the Crown have of course not been divulged... Costs that really should be paid for by the idiotic Minister who's ignored extensive advice, her own ministry's reports and overwhelming opposition to such an incomprehensibly dumb decision.

Parata's stupidity appears to be based on nothing more than saving a few bucks, money that can then be used to pay for the tax-cuts for the rich. National's ideological drive to save a few dollars with complete disregard for the consequences is actually costing the country dearly. We have increased costs of people having to fight the government in court and there are increased costs when things fail because decisions aren't being made in the best interests of the country and all its people.

As the clear frontrunner at ignoring advice, flip-flopping and generally stuffing up her portfolio, Parata has displayed a level of incompetence any Minister in all of New Zealand's political history would have trouble besting. There's no question that she should resign, and currently the only thing that's protecting her is arrogance and a completely deluded Prime Minister.

Today, the Nelson Mail reported:

Green Party co-leader Metiria Turei has called for Parata to be sacked after the judge's ruling.

Ms Turei said this was Ms Parata's "latest and most dangerous failure" and left her position untenable. She called on Prime Minister John Key to sack her.

National had also faced a public backlash over plans to close schools in Canterbury following the earthquakes.

"Hekia Parata's blatant disregard for the safety of girls at Salisbury College in Nelson must be the final straw,'' Ms Turei said.

Ms Parata was unwilling to listen and her refusal to heed warnings about pupil safety was "dangerous and extraordinarily arrogant."

"What kind of minister would put school girls in harm's way? You simply can' t have someone in the job who does that," she said.

20 Jul 2012

Not enough jobs for graduates

Today, the Listener reported (not online yet):

Online shopping site Mighty Ape, based in Auckland, advertised several months ago for customer service staff and ended up hiring an IT graduate and a film school graduate for entry-level positions, says company founder Simon Barton.

"We also advertised for a new warehouse monkey [staffer] and we had several graduates apply. I find this quite shocking. I'm not sure I would risk studying for three years only to find there are no suitable jobs in the market. The other issue we found striking was the number of people with film school or media studies backgrounds. Where are those jobs? Why are we teaching courses for these occupations if there are so few oppurtunities?" says Barton.

It's a good question. New Zealand has developed a somewhat privatised system of tertiary education, whereby providers are run largely independent of the government. This means that courses are promoted to potential clients even if there are no job placements available after graduation.

Instead of matching the number of placements to the potential job market, the system relies on students choosing courses, often with little or no information concerning future job prospects. In fact the only information a student is usually given is the course advertising, which paints a false picture to encourage enrollment.

It would defeat the purpose of the private institute to inform students that there's little hope of future employment in their chosen field of expertise and they would effectively be doing themselves out of a job. Nobody is going waste thousands of dollars on course fees when studying does not increase employment potential.

This is where the government should be acting decisively instead of leaving it up to the marketplace to dictate how many people are trained in each profession dependent upon how many applicants there are. The Ministry of Education should be looking at how many job placements are required, and funding accordingly.

There is of course some degree of scope, being that so many New Zealanders are leaving our shores and it's preferable that they have an opportunity to train beforehand. It's also worthwhile mentioning that some courses have benefits outside of employment... Adult Education courses for instance have huge payoffs for communities, especially in rural areas.

So this isn't just a failure of the private sector to create enough jobs, it's a failure of the government to regulate properly on how many people are trained accordingly. If National wants more student loan money returned, they must act to remedy the current dysfunction within our education system. Anything less is just a waste of time and money.

Considering the complete mess surrounding the planned teacher cuts, I somehow doubt the Minister of Education Hekia Parata has the brains to make the required changes.

10 Jun 2012

Myth-busting rightwing prejudices - class sizes

Last night, One news interviewed so-called education expert and governmental advisor John Hattie who claimed that changing the student teacher ratio didn't make much of a difference to student achievement. He was also on Q+A today, and was very unconvincing, displaying all the trademarks of presenting disinformation.

The first thing that struck me was how goddamn awful his presentation to treasury (PDF) looks. But more specifically the garishly presented and badly laid out data is all over the place and without proper reference to where it was sourced.

John Hattie
It claims that "Hundreds of evaluations of reducing class size has zero effect on achievement," but then claims that learning achievement is increased by 0.2 over time for intermediate and 0.4 for preschool.

Keep in mind that these numbers are not percentages; they're an effect size. Hattie also claims that finances available to a school have an effect size on student achievement of only 0.12. This would show that class size is in fact more important than funding.

But there's a huge contradiction here, with the garish report to treasury saying class size has an effect of 0, 0.2, 0.4, and this report by John Hattie from 2003 (PDF) that says the overall effect size is negative 0.05. This simply does not compute.

Hattie is claiming in the latter report that more students per teacher increase achievement outcomes. Around 96% of parents and teachers disagree with the confused professor, mainly because the more one on one teaching time a student gets, the better educational outcome is achieved.

The report also puts the effect size of instructional quality at 1.00. While there is no doubt that teacher quality has a large effect on educational outcomes, blaming teacher's fits nicely into the right-wings agenda, whereby they can cut funding and increase the amount of students in classrooms while criticizing teachers for the resulting low achievement outcomes. Approximately 7 to 20% of school leavers are technically illiterate in New Zealand.

To his credit, Professor Hattie states:

We need to direct attention at higher quality teaching, and higher expectations that students can meet appropriate challenges - and these occur once the classroom door is closed and not by reorganizing which or how many students are behind those doors, by promoting different topics for these teachers to teach, or by bringing in more sticks to ensure they are following policy.

But this does not excuse National's complete rubbish argument that teacher quality would be improved by increasing class sizes. Hattie has also contradicted himself by writing in 2003 that student/teacher ratios should not be changed, but then advises National that they should be. Perhaps he likes changing his message dependent on who is in power?

The main problem is that Hattie fails to find a long run impact on attainment, he measures the effect on small numbers of students where the variable is reduced, his conclusion does not use stringent conditions to decide what studies to disregard and many if not all of the studies he has used have methodological problems. This almost guarantees that Hattie's findings for the relationship between student/teacher ratio and student learning is biased.

So let's look at a few major international studies that are not biased:

The Impact of Class Size and Number of Students on Outcomes in Higher Education (PDF):

Reducing class sizes and the total number of students that a faculty member is responsible for teaching in a semester will lead to significant improvements in student outcomes.

Class size reduction in grade K-3 (PDF):

Reducing class size in Grades K-3 has been found to have academic benefits in all subject areas, especially for children living in poverty. Studies published since the mid-1980s show that classroom behavior and test scores improve while students are in small classes. Further, the improvement persists through the middle school and high school years, even though students return to full-size classes. To reap the full range of benefits, it is important that pupils enter small classes in the early years (Grades K or 1) and continue in small classes for three or more years. Students who attend small classes are also more likely to take college-entrance examinations; this is especially true for minority students.

The effect of class size on the teaching of pupils aged 7-11 years (PDF):

Practical tasks become less common, teacher demonstrations increase and pupils have less ‘hands on’ experience. So, though the curriculum coverage remains the same, the tasks through which it is experienced are different, and in some ways more superficial. However, this possible linkage between types of task and class size is mainly based on suggestions from the case studies and needs more thorough testing. 
[...] 
Our results suggest several other ways in which smaller classes allow opportunities for teaching, though these flow less obviously from less children in the class. The first is maximizing individualization and differentiation by teaching to small groups. This would have the benefits of interactive whole class teaching, but would be potentially more focused and better differentiated in terms of pupil ability. It is perhaps here that one might seek to maximize the effectiveness of individual attention. Other areas have been couched in terms consistent with Anderson’s (2000) model and include: personalized, appropriate instruction; more adventurous teaching that extends the teaching repertoire, a more active (less passive) role for pupils, that includes more opportunities for help seeking.

Conclusion: Whole class teaching is not an acceptable alternative to individual support of pupils’ learning, increasing the amount of students per teacher has a detrimental effect on learning and John Hattie should not be advising the government with biased research.

It's understandable that the garish report was laid out in a way that treasury officials and National politician's could understand, but the blatant contradiction between the two reports and Hattie claiming increasing class sizes improves student achievement gets a big fat F for fail!

8 Jun 2012

Hekia Parata - Asshole of the Week

The last couple of weeks have been an unmitigated disaster for Education Minister Hekia Parata. Not only was she unable to provide accuracy concerning a reduction in teacher student ratios, she entrenched herself deeply with rhetoric in the face of overwhelming opposition.

Nobody but the most ideologically blinded Nact supporter believed reducing the amount of teachers would equate to better learning outcomes, and teachers, parents and the wider community were entirely against the idea.

The policy change was a hard sell, and Parata bumbled and flip-flopped her way through interview after interview, which only served to annoy those who actually care about our children. The opposition had a field day, with mounting ammunition and public support at their backs, this turned into a lose lose scenario for National, who had no option but to back down.

Today, the NZ Herald reported:

No more compromises; just capitulation - complete and utter. Hekia Parata yesterday surrendered to the inevitable less than two days after saying she was not going to budge any further on the vexed question of teacher-pupil ratios.

Further compromise was never an option, however. It would not have silenced the education lobby groups. Those representatives of teachers, principals and boards of trustees would have continued to press for full reversal of the policy which would have seen many schools lose one or two teacher positions.

The Dominion Post reported:

A range of new cuts within the education spend will be sought, but some of the hole will almost certainly be filled by passing the cost on to the new spending allowance of next year's Budget.

That is sure to annoy Ms Parata's Cabinet colleagues and seriously undermine her stocks as a minister.

"I'm the minister and the buck stops with me – I'm accountable for these decisions," she said.

A shortfall of $174 million will still need to be found from cuts, which will mainly be made in the education sector. Parata has said this could come from teacher training, which would also have a negative effect on educational outcomes for students.

It's worth keeping in mind that National is spending $14 billion on new highways instead of improving teacher quality, which goes to show exactly where their priorities lie.

National's changes to teacher student ratios was a badly researched, poorly thought out and terribly executed policy that threatened to kick education in the guts. Their failure to spin enough propaganda and humiliating backdown will have lost them support.

As the Minister of Education, the buck stops with Hekia Parata... She should resign.

2 Jun 2012

Delusional

Today, the Dominion Post reported:

The Greater Wellington Secondary School Principals' Association has rejected claims it gave Education Minister Hekia Parata a standing ovation, saying its custom is to stand when a Crown minister enters and leaves the room.
A press secretary for Ms Parata said on Thursday the minister had been given a standing ovation after she gave a speech to the association in Wellington's Thorndon.
Reporters, who had been trailing Ms Parata after she was heckled by protesters at a speech earlier that morning, were not able to verify the account because the minister said they could not cover the speech as it was a private event.

There's no way in hell that the Secondary School Principals' Association would give Hekia Parata a standing ovation. They think she's failed to do her homework after all.

Let's hear from somebody that attended who isn't deluded:

The Greater Wellington Secondary School Principals Association chairwoman and principal of St Mary's College, Mary Cook, said members of her organisation stood and "clapped lightly" for Ms Parata after she thanked her for the speech.
"If it had been a standing ovation there would have been lots of cheering and very loud hand clapping, I can assure you. People stood out of respect for her position."
Mrs Cook said she was unaware of the custom of other associations but her organisation had always done so.
"We've had lots of ministers since I've been principal of St Mary's and everyone of them, no matter what we thought of them privately or collectively, has been welcomed and farewelled in the same way."
Members were very upset about the changes. "None of us are supportive of them."

This might seem like a small thing but it's actually a real concern. These people are meant to be running the country and such delusions of grandeur are indicative of the dysfunction that is rife throughout National party ranks. They are divorced from reality.

Mind you, considering the "credentials" of the press secretaries boss, I guess we should be happy they're not completely brain dead.

31 May 2012

Idiot in charge of education

Minister for Education and all round fashion disaster Hekia Parata has undertaken a huge flip-flop concerning policy changes outlined in National's zero budget.

After copping flak about increased class sizes, which will result in fewer teachers, Parata now claims that there will be a transition period paid for by a mystical contingency fund and no school will lose more than two teachers.

Today, One News reported:

PPTA President Robin Duff said the cuts amounted to a $300 million claw back of school staffing over the next five years.

He said technology education would take a hit in particular.

"Subject options will have to be cut and area schools and junior high schools will no longer be able to function the way they were designed to operate."

The Government has already altered its original policy this week and said that no more than two full-time teaching staff would be lost at any school in the next three years.

Duff rejects Parata's claim that the fewer cuts was "good news".

"Losing one teacher is a bad thing for any school, losing two will be a disaster for most."

Duff said arguments that the cuts were designed to improve teacher quality were "fundamentally dishonest" as the evidence showed Treasury and Government had been preparing for them since well before the 2011 election.

It's completely ludicrous that Parata thinks cutting teacher numbers is somehow a positive thing, when every study shows that fewer students per teacher equals better outcomes.

This clearly shows that National is not undertaking their budget cuts with appropriate care and they simply don't give a damn about the effects of their badly researched austerity measures.

Here's what the idiot Minister of Education said on Tuesday:

Iain Lees-Galloway: How is it fair for small intermediate schools to lose the same number of teachers as large intermediate schools, which is what her new, ad hoc plan that she made up on the way to the House will implement?

Hon HEKIA PARATA: We wrote on Budget day to all schools, telling them that a transition plan would be put into place and that we would work with each of them. In the interests of providing certainty now, we have provided the guarantee that no school will lose more than two full-time teacher equivalents, and 90 percent will not lose any more than one full-time teacher equivalent. This is good news.

Yesterday, Parata again tried to avoid answering direct questions on the matter, but eventually confirmed that she did not have advice concerning the impact on specific schools.


Having to make changes to and effectively re-write the budget before the inks even dry is gross incompetence that only a National government could display.

Hekia Parata doesn't even know how many teachers overall will lose their jobs because of National's destructive policy changes, yet can still claim that teaching outcomes are going to improve.

No wonder teachers and parents are up in arms.

1 Mar 2012

Parata steps over the bounds of decency

Yesterday, Labour MP Nanaia Mahuta asked the Minister of Education, Hekia Parata:

Does she have confidence in her Ministry?

What followed was a despicable display of arrogance from Hekia Parata, where she exhibited nastiness and incompetently misled the House of Representatives:


No kidding there is room for improvement.

So Parata went home for the weekend leaving the parents none the wiser about the child sex offender. The Minister of Education obviously had access to the name and home contact details of the school principle, who in turn has the contact details of the parents whose children had interacted with the known sexual offender. A phone call would have been a far more appropriate way for them to be informed. Leaving it up to the Six O'clock news to do the job is not acceptable.

Parata then made a press statement where she attempted to gain support for the Privacy (Information Sharing) Bill... completely ignoring the fact that the failure to share information on the sexual offender who was breaching his bail conditions by working in schools had nothing to do with the current privacy laws. The agencies involved had the legal power and should have intervened.

It is despicable that National is trying to gain political ground over such an issue, especially when it's ultimately the Ministers responsibility to ensure such failings do not occur.

Today, National party apologist Mai Chen had an opinion piece in the NZ Herald called ‘Sex offender case shows law’s limits’. However this statement is quickly contradicted:

The Privacy Act does not stop you from sharing information when it needs to be shared. In most circumstances relating to the protection of vulnerable children, there will be an exemption when you need it - such as health and safety reasons (where there is a serious and imminent threat) and the maintenance of the law, including the prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution, and punishment of offences (Information Privacy Principles 10 and 11, section 6, Privacy Act).

There simply should not have been such incompetence that allowed a known sexual offender the ability to work with young vulnerable children. Somebody should be held to account for such mismanagement.

National attempting to gain political support for the Privacy (Information Sharing) Bill that has nothing to do with this case is simply abhorrent!

In the four seminars we did in Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin for the Social Service Providers Aotearoa Inc on these issues, concerns were raised about whether the bill should mandate reporting of suspected child abuse. That is a separate issue that would be difficult to accommodate in the narrow scope of this bill.

After running a half page promoting the Privacy (Information Sharing) Bill, Mai Chen then admits that it would have no proper way to increase information sharing on suspected child abusers anyway. Why then is Parata trying to gain public support for the bill on the back of such incompetence?

The question is; do the actions of criminals and the need to ensure the publics safety outweigh peoples right to privacy? As a law-abiding citizen I have serious reservations about the actions of criminals impinging on my right to privacy. That, to a degree, is letting the criminals win. I also do not think it's appropriate that government institutions can simply agree to not adhere to the Privacy Act where it suits them, which is what the Privacy (Information Sharing) Bill is proposing.

A law change is not required when there is an obvious imminent and serious threat to public safety, and the current laws are already designed to ensure the public is protected. It is the procedures and management that is the problem here, not the current laws. People weren't doing their jobs properly, and heads should roll.

Parata should not be trying to gain political ground out of the institutional incompetence she is responsible for. In doing so, Hekia Parata has stepped over the bounds of decency and should consider resigning.

10 Feb 2012

Friday fun with photos #13

On Wednesday, stuff.co.nz reported:

Earthquake Recovery Minister Gerry Brownlee has entered the political fray consuming the city council, calling Mayor Bob Parker a ''clown''.

So who are the real clowns?

28 Jan 2012

Pike River broken promises


It's been fourteen months since the Pike River Mine first exploded in November 2010, trapping 29 miners inside. Five days later and after the second explosion occurred, they were all presumed not to have survived.

Despite continued assurances that the government would do everything in its power to recover the deceased, they have remained entombed in the mine. To date, there's been very little progress to retrieve the 29 miners... so why the interminable delay?

Back in September 2011, TVNZ reported:

Key said his position on returning the miners to their loved ones has never changed. He said he promised from the outset that he would do everything he could to recover the bodies and that promise remains.

But he said the families fully understand the situation and realise that it would not be wise to put other lives at risk.

Key also told the families of the miners that he would discuss with Cabinet extending the funding of the families' legal team beyond the Royal Commission.

"I've always said if there aren't enough resources from Oil and Gas they can come talk to the Government, it's not an issue of money."

Unfortunately it is an issue of money. Instead of accepting some responsibility for the disaster, the government has allowed the receivers to make the retrieval of the miners a condition of the sale. This has assuredly meant a delay.

Back in July last year, Acting Minister of Energy and Resources, Hekia Parata welcomed the receivers’ decision:

The Government supports the approach being taken by the Pike River receivers to seek a commitment from any purchaser of the mine to take all reasonable steps to recover the miners’ bodies.

[...]

“The challenges faced at the Pike River mine are complex. We fully understand the desire of the West Coast community, and especially the immediate families of the miners, to have their bodies retrieved from the mine.

“We are seeking to proceed in a way that offers the best chance of recovering the miners’ bodies, and restoring to the West Coast a working mine at Pike River, if it is possible to do so.”

Clearly Parata does not understand the desire of the West Coast Community, because she supported the receivers decision that has ultimately delayed the retrieval process.

What we need to see is some real leadership on this issue, but instead all we seem to get is more broken promises:

Key said he will call the receivers personally to discuss a recovery plan but just who will implement it will not be known until there is a new owner for Pike River Mine.

The receivers say a decision could be several weeks away.

The families are hoping that promises made today will not be forgotten after November's election.

Several weeks away? Try several months, and perhaps several years. Yesterday, TVNZ reported:

Engineer Bruce McLean was commissioned by the families to write a report examining possible issues around reclaiming the mine tunnel and recovering the men's bodies.

His report concludes that if there is a successful sale of the mine, recovery of the bodies could be completed between July 2015 and June 2017, dependent on a number of factors, including completion of a new shaft to establish ventilation in the mine.

His estimated time frames include conditions attached to the sale, such as potential Oversees Investment Office approval, transfer of permits, and agreeing on recovery obligations.

[...]

New Zealand Oil and Gas (NZOG), which held significant shareholdings in Pike River, recently acknowledged that the mine may not be able to be sold.

In such a case the role of the government would become 'critical' says Counsel for the families, Nicholas Davidson QC.

It's bad enough that the families and not the government commissioned the report, but it's totally unacceptable that a decision as to who will be responsible for the retrieval of the deceased miners hasn't even been made yet.

The government is clearly being remiss in its duties by allowing a financial and not moral decision to be made. John Key should not be disregarding the wishes of the miners families and the many thousands of other New Zealander's who want some closure on Pike River mine.

Having the retrieval dependent on the sale of Pike River when this might never occur is completely unacceptable.

In my opinion, people who make promises without any intention of keeping them are the lowest of the low... and in this case; such things are a cruelty on the affected families. Breaking promises is definitely not how a Prime Minister should be conducting himself.

29 Oct 2011

Hekia Parata - Asshole of the Week Award

Not only did we have to put up with Hekia Parata's bold faced lies that New Zealand had the resources and manpower to deal with an oil spill the size of Deepwater Horizon… we now have to put up with oil and dead animals washing up all over our beaches precisely because she was lying.

Hekia Parata is a face lifted bitch that wouldn’t know the truth if it came up and bit her on her rather large and saggy posterior.

Parata’s lies are going to cost this country millions if not billions of dollars.

Our clean and green image is in tatters while Parata continues to bleat on about how great deep sea oil drilling is. Instead of waking up to reality, the cow totally ignores the wishes of the vast majority of New Zealanders who think drilling for oil in deep waters without any proper oil spill response capabilities is madness.

Parata said she’d consulted with local East coast Iwi concerning deep-water oil drilling in their ancestral waters when she had not. Her corrupt governance wastes public money on illegal Police surveillance of environmentalists to benefit her oily masters.
The Associate and Acting Minister of Energy and Resources has provided false figures to the public concerning the social benefit of the oil and gas industry when most of the profits go offshore. The vast majority of the workers are foreigners and there is very little benefit to New Zealand while we carry the burden when something goes wrong.

Thanks to National the maximum fines able to be imposed on companies that cause environmental disasters are pathetically woeful. Parata was repeatedly warned of this fact prior to the Rena disaster, but chose to do nothing.

The Dynasty queen grand stands about the Maui gas leak like it’s just another photo op while businesses are losing millions of dollars… all because National once again failed to ensure the infrastructure was properly maintained. Infrastructure that was not built by Kiwis I might ad.

Here she is misleading the House of Representatives with her lies:



So for being a fashion disaster, repeated and blatant lies concerning New Zealand’s oil spill response capabilities and being a kupapa… Hekia Parata is this weeks Asshole Award winner... it’s about time.

20 Oct 2011

National's Blighted Future Plan








7 Oct 2011

BOP Oil Spill Response Failure

Authorities have dismally failed to react properly to the grounding of the 236-metre cargo vessel MV Rena, which struck Astrolabe Reef north of Motiti Island in the Bay of Plenty on Wednesday at approx 2.20 AM.

The Rena is reported to be carrying hazardous materials and an estimated 1500 tonnes of heavy fuel oil on board.

Although authorities initially tried to downplay the serious nature of the incident, a large amount of oil started leaking from the vessel after a pumping operation to move fuel from one side of the vessel to the other was undertaken. The oil was initially reported to be hydrolic fluid.

An attempt to chemically disperse the oil has failed, with the spill being reported yesterday as over five kilometers in length. The oil will wash up on surrounding shorelines and some birds have already been found dead.

Today, the Bay of Plenty Times reported that Maritime New Zealand was managing the operation and has declared a Tier 3 Response, due to the size and complexity of the grounding. However this is not strictly the case.

Yesterday, it was reported that the Director of Maritime New Zealand, Catherine Taylor issued the owner of the stricken cargo vessel with two notices under section 248 of the Maritime Transport Act 1994. This does not put MNZ in charge of the operation, but gives MNZ the ability to take control off the salvage company Svitzer, if MNZ deems it necessary. Under the Maritime Transport Act, the owners of the ship are liable for minner penalties, and a maximum fine of $200,000.

Earlier today, Transport Minister Steven Joyce said the situation was worse than first thought, that there was a "significant amount of oil" and the vessel could break up due to its "precarious" position on the reef.

However Joyce did not give any details of what equipment was available to clean up the oil slick, remove what oil and fuel remain on the vessel or that the government had any plans to ensure the proper removal of whatever hazardous materials are on board. With bad weather predicted, the government seems unwilling to act to avert the disaster from escalating.

Back in April this year, the associate and acting Minister for Energy and Resources, Hekia Parata was questioned by Green MP David Clendon about New Zealand's oil spill capabilities:
Hon HEKIA PARATA: Maritime New Zealand is responsible for ensuring New Zealand is prepared for, and able to respond to, marine oil spills. The Marine Pollution Response Service consists of internationally respected experts who manage and train a team of around 400 local government and Maritime New Zealand responders. New Zealand has equipment and other stores strategically located around New Zealand. In addition, the Marine Pollution Response Service assists regional councils with exercise and oil spill equipment. The plan is responsive and is regularly evaluated to ensure it meets changing risk profiles.
It seems strange that we need to fly in experts from overseas when Parata said we already have "internationally respected experts" here in New Zealand already. Today, the Leader of NZ First, Winston Peters made some very good points about the lack of an adequate response to the incident:
More than 72 hours after the grounding of the MV Rena, with over 1500 tonnes of oil on board, at the Astrolabe Reef off Tauranga the lack of urgency and inertia demonstrated by the Government is to be deplored.

Sitting around waiting for some overseas expert to arrive is surely not the answer. Shippers have for years paid a fee to cover such an event. Now that it is here the public should be demanding to know, where is Prime Minister Key, Transport Minister Joyce or Environmental Minister Smith.

The oil should be taken off the boat now as should any dangerous cargo. That is not what is happening. Moreover the dispersal agent being used is likely to be as dangerous as the oil itself because its characteristics are to take the oil to the sea floor where it’s danger to the marine ecology will have tragic effects.

Hekia Parata said New Zealand had the equipment to be able to respond to marine oil spills. This was clearly a blatant lie as there has been no equipment deployed to contain or clean up the leaking oil.

23 Sept 2011

Power Corrupts

The latest edition of the Listener has an article entitled Cold Comfort, which is all about New Zealand’s high electricity prices and how they contribute to ill health. It makes for sober reading, especially when considering that the continuing trend of high electricity prices and low incomes is going to make things a lot worse.

It's estimated that 400,000 New Zealand homes are not adequately heated, because the inhabitants live below the fuel poverty rate where warming a home eats up more than 10% of a households income.

But what pisses me off the most is the huge increase in the cost of electricity over the last few years when we have an abundant and cheap supply. In comparison to the initial expenditure on infrastructure, there has been very little spent on maintenance or upgrading the system.

The University of Otago found that electricity prices have risen by a whopping 87% over ten years to May 2011. Lead author of a report quoted in the Listener article, Philippa Howden-Chapman said that cold homes probably play a role in an extra 1600 deaths each winter. The report showed that countries with much colder climates do not have as high a mortality rate as New Zealand.
“We found that fuel poverty is a major issue in New Zealand, particularly for people on low incomes, and it’s a problem that’s growing,”  Philippa said.
The Listener article written by Ruth Laugesen goes on to say that the jump in fuel poverty in New Zealand appears driven by a troika of causes – low incomes, rising electricity prices and New Zealand’s crummy, badly insulated housing stock.
"We’ve had several instances of homes we’ve visited where the children are away [from school] as much as one or two days a week on average. They’re spending $300, maybe $400, a month. Their house still isn’t particularly warm, but it’s getting mouldy because it’s damp and slightly warm. They’ve got these huge power bills and they’re really at their wits’ end,” said Sarah Free, a senior energy adviser for the Sustainable Trust.
Despite the unarguable truth of the situation, Associate Minister of Energy and Resources, Hekia Parata just had to try and put a positive spin on things:
“Competition in energy supply provides choice to consumers and places downward pressure on prices. The reforms make it easier for more electricity retailers to operate across New Zealand, so customers have more choice of providers,” Parata said.
What a load of codswallop! This is what National did:
  • Meridian Energy, Genesis Energy and Mighty River Power had a virtual asset swap.
  • National required all major electricity generators to put in place an electricity hedge market, to help commercial consumers to get even cheaper power.
  • National established a $15 million fund over three years to promote customer switching between retailers.
  • National abolished the Electricity Commission and replaced it with a slimmed-down Electricity Authority.
None of these things gave New Zealander's cheaper power... In fact the article states that household electricity prices rose by 4% more than inflation each year in the decade to 2010.

Market reforms have been all about getting the SOE's ready to sell and giving commercial consumers even cheaper power, at the public's expense.
Increased price of electricity for the public.